Pick it up and the first thing you’ll notice is how little it weighs. At just 3.3 pounds, with sidewalls about as thick as a U.S. nickel and a silky-smooth cooking surface, this Favorite Piqua Ware No. 8 shows how finely American foundries could cast and finish a skillet. Then turn it over. The curved Favorite Piqua Ware Smiley sits above a crisp MIAMI diamond, with the number 8 near the handle. Two foundry marks, one beautifully made pan.

The sort of skillet that can steal a Griswold owner’s heart

If you judge vintage iron by how it feels in the hand, this is a Favorite that could earn the front burner over a Griswold. The thin walls keep it easy to lift, the two pour spouts make it easy to tip, and the smooth, seasoned interior is what you hope to find when you pick up an old skillet. Best of all, it sits dead flat on marble, with no spin and no cracks. That combination makes it as appealing for Sunday breakfast as it is for a cast iron collection.

Two marks from one Ohio foundry

Favorite Stove & Range Co. moved from Cincinnati to Piqua, Ohio, and its plant there began operating in 1889. Stoves and ranges were the foundation of the business, but Favorite also turned out skillets, griddles, Dutch ovens, and waffle irons. Favorite Piqua Ware carried the company’s flagship name, and Miami was another cookware line from the same foundry. Here, both names are cast into the base. Collectors generally place this Smiley and Miami Diamond combination around 1916–1935. The curved line under “WARE” is what gives the Smiley its nickname.

The story behind “MIAMI”

If that diamond makes you think of South Florida, there’s a story worth telling the next time someone turns the pan over. The foundry’s Miami name points to Miami County, Ohio, where Piqua sits along the Great Miami River. The Ohio name honors the Myaamia, or Miami people, whose homelands in the southern Great Lakes included parts of present-day Ohio and Indiana. Many Myaamia were forcibly removed west beginning in 1846. Today, the Miami Tribe of Oklahoma continues to revitalize its language and share its history. Florida’s Miami has a separate Indigenous origin in Mayaimi, a name associated with Lake Okeechobee and often translated as “very large lake.”

Size and condition

This is the kind of heirloom that earns its place by getting used. Put a crust on cornbread, fry up the family’s Sunday breakfast, or hang it with both marks facing out. Years from now, when somebody asks for the pan you always used, this could be the one they mean.