X-Men #4 (Marvel, March 1964) — the first appearance of Quicksilver, the Scarlet Witch, the Toad and Mastermind and the debut of Magneto's Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, with a Jack Kirby cover. An honest, complete 4.0 Very Good copy of a major Silver Age key.

Key Debuts and Story Milestones

Behind the Scenes and Quirky Details

Condition:

FRONT
Magneto's chest — a cluster of colour-breaking creases about 1″ × 1″, a spidered network of white lines in the red and black just above the purple cape, with a short tail of lines running down toward the X-Men on the tabletop. It crosses the printed linework, so it is wear rather than art, and it sits in the centre of the cover. This is the defect that sets the grade — HIGH impact to the grade
X logo — several small pale patches of rubbed-off yellow ink (⅛″–3/16″) on the arms of the big X, and a small grey smudge of soiling on its left arm — MED impact to the grade
Edges and corners — short creases along the top edge; top-right and bottom-right corners rounded, the other two worn; scattered short creases in the green along the right edge — MED impact to the grade
Surface — gloss dulled across the red with light general rubbing. No writing, stamps or stickers — LOW impact to the grade

SPINE
Edge wear — fraying and multiple small chips along most of the spine, with a small notch in the lower third and ink rubbed off the blue corner box — MED impact to the grade
Roll — the spine has rolled toward the back, so both staples sit on the back cover about ⅛″ in from the fold, with puckering and small tears at the staples. Two original staples, grey metal, no rust, and the cover is still attached (checked in hand). Please see the back-cover close-ups — MED impact to the grade

BACK
Surface — the Mason Shoe ad is fairly clean, with one short crease in the suitcase artwork and light soiling — LOW impact to the grade
Corners — all four close to square, and the Mason coupon is uncut — No impact on the grade.

INTERIOR
Tape — a piece of clear tape, about ¾″ × 1⅛″, on the coin-ad page facing page 13, over the upper staple at the gutter. The part over the staple has aged to amber; the rest is clearer and runs across the “$1” of the REWARD ad. The tape surface is lifting slightly in two small spots. Two thin green lines, probably a previous owner’s pen, sit beneath it beside the staple. Checked in hand: there is no tear under the tape, and the cover and centrefold are both still attached at the staples. Shown in the interior photo — LOW impact to the grade
Lower staple — the paper is slightly pushed up where the top of the lower staple passes through; a small pull, not a tear. Staple clean, no rust — LOW impact to the grade
Page quality — cream to off-white, supple, no brittleness — LOW impact to the grade
Coupons — the Hypno-Coin coupon on the page shown is uncut — No impact on the grade.

Graded 4.0 (Very Good), honest range 3.5–4.5. A complete, readable copy of a major key with the wear in plain view: the crease cluster on Magneto's chest, a frayed and rolled spine, and a small piece of tape inside. At arm's length the Kirby lineup is all there and the colours are still strong, nothing is cut, and there is no writing on the covers.

Please note: The grade above is my own opinion on a raw, uncertified comic and is offered in good faith — it is not a certified grade from CGC, CBCS or any other grading service. This copy is unsigned, with no writing, stamps or stickers on either cover; the only hand marks are two thin green lines, probably pen, under the interior tape. It is the US 12¢ first printing, not the UK pence-price variant or a reprint, and it predates the direct market. The photographs are of the actual comic you will receive: twelve high-resolution views: both covers, two raking-light shots of the spine, the interior tape, and close-ups of seven corners (every corner with a recorded defect). The book ships bagged and boarded in a rigid cardboard mailer.