X-Men #9 (Marvel, January 1965) is the first time the X-Men meet the Avengers and the first appearance of Lucifer, with a Jack Kirby and Chic Stone cover and a Stan Lee and Jack Kirby story.

Key Debuts and Story Milestones

Behind the Scenes and Quirky Details

Condition:

FRONT
Ink — a previous owner drew a small red-ink diamond, about ¾ in across, in the centre of the yellow “X” of the X-MEN logo, where the two strokes cross. It is hand-drawn on top of the printing, not a signature. Graded as defacement; please see the front-cover and top-left close-up photos — MED impact to the grade
Corners — all four blunted. The bottom-right tip is rubbed, with a little surface paper lost at the point and a short colour-breaking crease rising from the bottom edge. There are small colour-breaking creases on the top edge by the Comics Code box — LOW impact to the grade
Gloss and colour — bright and flat, with light rub. The yellow logo and Kirby’s reds hold up well — LOW impact to the grade

SPINE
Stress lines — heavy fraying along the full length of the spine, with many colour-breaking stress lines. Short colour-breaking creases run in from the spine: about ½ in at the bottom of the MARVEL/12¢ box and about 1 in along Cyclops’s beam. This is the defect that sets the grade — HIGH impact to the grade
Structure — the fold is continuous with no split visible in two raking shots, and the book lies flat. Two original staples — No impact on the grade.

BACK
Surface — crinkle creasing, heaviest in the upper left, which does not break colour on the white ad. Light handling soil and tanned edges — LOW impact to the grade
Corners — lightly blunted, with small creases at the bottom right. The coupon is uncut — LOW impact to the grade

INTERIOR
Page quality — cream to off-white, with tanned outer margins. No loose pages in the spread shown — LOW impact to the grade

Graded 3.5 (Very Good−), honest range 3.0–4.0. A complete, bright, flat copy of a two-key early Kirby X-Men. On the paper alone it is a 4.0: honest spine wear, with no split and no missing pieces. The previous owner’s red-ink diamond on the logo takes it down half a grade.

Please note: The grade above is my own opinion on a raw, uncertified comic, offered in good faith. It is not a certified grade from CGC, CBCS or any other grading service. This copy is unsigned; the red ink on the logo is a previous owner’s doodle, not an autograph. It is the original US 12¢ printing, with no restoration found. The photographs are of the actual comic you will receive. There are 12 views: the front and back covers, two raking shots of the spine, an interior spread, and the corners. It ships bagged and boarded in a rigid mailer.