Ghostly Haunts #40 (Charlton, September 1974, 25¢) carries Tom Sutton's spider-web cover, signed “Grisly” in the art, in its original printing, with stories by Steve Ditko, Wayne Howard and Sutton himself inside.
No first appearances in this issue. What it has is one of Sutton's best Charlton covers and a strong line-up inside.
Condition:
FRONT
Creases — two thin vertical creases running down from the top edge through the Comics Code box at the top right; they break colour — MED impact to the grade
Corners — top-left and bottom-left lightly blunted with a little whitening; top-right and bottom-right rounded — LOW impact to the grade
Surface — fine scuffs and rubbed specks across the black web background, gloss reduced but present; colours still bold — LOW impact to the grade
SPINE
Stress ticks — about a dozen short colour-breaking ticks along the fold, each under ¼″, mostly in the top half — MED impact to the grade
Structure — straight and flat with no roll, checked in raking light — No impact on the grade.
BACK
Closed tear — about 2″, running down from the top edge through the “Have you seen this” headline into the coupon text; no paper missing. This is the defect that sets the grade — HIGH impact to the grade
Lower staple — paper torn away around the lower staple at the spine edge, about ⅜″, with the staple showing — MED impact to the grade
Soiling — grey-brown mottling and toning across the back cover — LOW impact to the grade
Corners — square — No impact on the grade.
INTERIOR
Page quality — Cream, with tanned margins; the paper bends cleanly, not brittle — LOW impact to the grade
Pages — complete, coupon uncut — No impact on the grade.
Graded 3.5 (Very Good−), honest range 3.0–4.0. The front still shows the cover well: Sutton's spider and web are bold and the colours hold. What sets the grade is the back cover, where a closed tear runs about 2 inches down from the top edge. The torn paper at the lower staple, two creases through the Code box and a run of spine ticks add to it. A reader-grade copy of a cover people want.
Please note: The grade above is my own opinion on a raw, uncertified comic and is offered in good faith — it is not a certified grade from CGC, CBCS or any other grading service. “Grisly” is Tom Sutton's printed signature in the artwork, not an autograph; this copy is unsigned, with no hand-applied writing, stamp or sticker. It predates the direct market and is the original 1974 printing. The photographs are of the actual comic you will receive: twelve high-resolution views including close-ups of all eight corners, a raking-light shot of the spine and an interior spread. The book ships bagged and boarded in a rigid cardboard mailer.