Werewolf by Night #1 (Marvel, September 1972, 20¢) is Jack Russell's first solo title and the start of the ongoing series, with a cover and interiors by Mike Ploog and a Darkhold story written by Gerry Conway.
Condition:
FRONT
Corners — top-left slightly rounded and top-right lightly blunted, each with a few fine crinkle creases in the red border just inside the tip; bottom-left (spine side) with a short colour-breaking crease line in the red; bottom-right blunted with light whitening and a short crinkle above it. No full corner folds — LOW to MED impact to the grade
Edges — a few small rubs on the red at the trim, mostly along the top. No chips, no tears — LOW impact to the grade
Surface, gloss and flatness — flat, bright and glossy, bold red. No creases across the cover, no writing, no stamps — No impact on the grade.
SPINE
Stress ticks — about a dozen short colour-breaking ticks along the fold, roughly 1/16″ to 1/4″ each, densest in the top third, shown in the raking-light photo. This is the defect that sets the grade — MED impact to the grade
Structure — straight, flush on the page block, no roll, no split, checked in raking light — No impact on the grade.
BACK
Toning and soil — the ad's background has toned to a warm cream, with light handling soil in the open areas; no stains — LOW impact to the grade
Corners — square to lightly softened — No impact on the grade.
INTERIOR
Page quality — Cream, supple, not brittle — LOW impact to the grade
Pages — complete centrefold, coupon uncut, no tears — No impact on the grade.
Graded 6.0 (Fine), honest range 5.5–6.5. A bright, glossy, flat copy of a wanted Bronze Age #1. What holds it at Fine is the spine — a full run of small colour-breaking ticks where the cover has been flexed open — plus four corners that have each picked up a little rounding and a few crinkles. Nothing is torn or missing.
Please note: The grade above is my own opinion on a raw, uncertified comic and is offered in good faith — it is not a certified grade from CGC, CBCS or any other grading service. The “Ploog” signature discussed above is printed artwork, not an autograph; this copy is unsigned, with no hand-applied writing, stamp or sticker anywhere on it. It predates the direct market and is the original 1972 first printing. The photographs are of the actual comic you will receive: twelve high-resolution views including both covers, a raking-light shot of the spine, the centrefold and close views of all eight corners. The book ships bagged and boarded in a rigid cardboard mailer.