These plates do show some wear. The gold has rubbed off of one and they do have some utensil marks. See pictures

The Vintage Hall's Superior Autumn Leaf 9” Plate is a classic piece of American pottery from 1955, featuring a traditional round shape with a glossy finish. This three-piece set includes decorative plates adorned with the iconic Autumn Leaf pattern in a vibrant multi-color palette. Hand wash only, these ceramic plates are a beautiful addition to any table setting, perfect for all occasions. The Hall brand's art pottery production style and mid 20th-century design make these plates a sought-after collectible for those who appreciate vintage dinnerware.