C.G. KELSEY OUTRAGE Huntington NY Tar & Feathered Lynching Murder 1873 Newspaper 
 
Offered is an original, collectible newspaper (NOT a copy/reproduction): THE NEW YORK TIMES, Dec. 16, 1872

* Warrants for Indictments coming
* Charles G. Kelsey outrage case
* Tar & feathered murder scandal
* Huntington, Long Island, New York

Page 3 has a brief report with a small, discrete heading: "The Kelsey Case at Huntington" (see image)

Complete in 8 pages, nice condition.

Note: The "Kelsey Outrage" of 1873 stands as one of Long Island's most notorious and gruesome crimes, involving the abduction, mutilation, and presumed murder of Charles G. Kelsey, a well-known schoolteacher, poet, and farmer from Huntington, New York.
On the evening of November 4, 1872, following a political rally, Kelsey was lured to a secluded area by a group of men. There, he was forcibly stripped, his head shaved, and he was tarred and feathered—a form of public humiliation. This was the last time he was seen alive. Despite the uproar and accusations of murder, Smith married Royal Sammis in June of 1873. Three months later, in August, Kelsey's mutilated remains—specifically, his legs and torso—were discovered floating in Cold Spring Harbor by two fishermen.
The incident, dubbed the "Kelsey Outrage," garnered national media attention and left an indelible mark on Huntington, which became colloquially known as "Tar Town." The community was deeply divided, with residents aligning as either "Tars" or "Anti-Tars," reflecting their stance on the mob's actions. The phrase "as dead as Kelsey's nuts" emerged from this event and persisted in the vernacular for decades. 
 
  Please Note: All of our offerings are 100% authentic! We do not offer reprints or reproductions of any kind. They are guaranteed to be original!  

Links to Archival Storage Options & Certificates of Authenticity Are Below!
 
Historical reports may be beautiful or ugly, but they are always informative. While we rejoice in the beautiful (heroic, discovery, amazing feats, etc.), we at History's Newsstand also offer "the ugly" for we are determined to learn from the wrongs of the past - understanding, to do so, we must be willing to look these wrongs directly in the face and shout "NO MORE!". It is for this reason many Black Americans collect historic slave ads, Jews collect reports regarding the Holocaust, women collect coverage of the Women's Suffrage Movement, etc.. If you find any to be offensive, we agree! Hopefully this is an indication we are moving in the right direction.

 
Domestic Shipping Policy...
  1. For this specific item, A U.S. winner pays $10.00 S&H. If multiple items are purchased and paid for simultaneously, the S&H will be calculated by using the highest item's S&H as the base cost, and then adding a small amount for each additional newspaper. The per-item additional cost for newspapers, folders, portfolios, and presentation cases vary according to size and weight.
  2. All U.S. orders include in-house insurance at no additional cost to the buyer and include delivery confirmation.
  3. All orders include tracking & delivery confirmation.
  4. Orders ship within 24 business hours of receiving payment.
  5. Some small items may be shipped 1st Class.  We will still provide tracking and insure them at our expense.
Combined Shipping Notice
If the automated eBay checkout process does not properly combine shipping, we will refund overages automatically. If you prefer, contact us prior to payment to obtain a revised invoice.
 
International Shipping Policy...
  1. If the S&H to your location is not given, international buyers/winners should contact us for an invoice which includes S&H.
  2. Import duties, taxes, VAT. etc. are not included in our quoted S&H. These charges are the buyer’s responsibility.
  3. Note:  We will not falsify customs declarations or mark an item as a "gift" in order to avoid customs fees.
  4. If insurance is desired, be in touch for a quote. All insured orders are subject to customs, duties, & taxes for the amount insured and are the buyer's responsibility.
  5. International purchasers are encouraged to take advantage of our combined shipping policy to lower the cost per item S&H. If you wish to take advantage of combined shipping, please do not pay for any until you are finished - and then contact us for a combined invoice.
If You Are Unhappy With Your Order
We make every effort to provide the best possible buying experience. If we fall short of your expectations in any way, please contact us so we can try to make things right for you.
Archival Storage...
...is available for an additional $15.00, plus an appropriate adjustment to S&H (see above Shipping Policy). If desired, purchase this directly (through eBay) at: archival storage folder. Again, to insure you will receive the appropriately sized folder for your item, please select the $15.00 folder option.
 
Certificate of Authenticity...
A certificate of authenticity is also available for an additional $3.00, which includes both the issue date and title, and certifies, by Timothy Hughes Rare & Early Newspapers, the issue to be authentic & original. If desired, purchase this directly (through eBay) at:   certificate of authenticity.
 
 
 
About Us... Contact Information...

We have been both collectors and dealers in rare newspapers since 1975, serve as consultants to multiple museums, and are members of both the Ephemera Society of America and the American Antiquarian Society. Bid & Buy with confidence knowing every item we offer is guaranteed to be authentic. 

Timothy Hughes Rare Newspapers
P.O. Box 3636
Williamsport, PA 17701-8636

Hours:  M-F, 7:30-4:00 EST

View our additional ebay offerings


 "...desiring to conduct ourselves honorably in all things." Heb. 13:18 

In an effort to honor eBay's policies and our loyal customers who watch our listings,
we do not end auction items early.  We hope you understand!
  "Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter." Thomas Jefferson