✅ YES — they are the SAME part (core component).

But there is 1 important difference 👇

🔍 What matches (same part)

• Same side: Driver / Left

• Same vehicles:

  • 2015–2020 Chevrolet Suburban

  • 2015–2020 Cadillac Escalade ESV

  • 2015–2020 GMC Yukon XL

• Same exact OEM part numbers:

  • 84452642 ✅

  • 84131859

  • 23433888

  • 22935835

👉 That means the motor itself is identical

⚠️ Key difference (VERY IMPORTANT)

🧩 Item 1 (your item)

• Comes with:

  • ✅ Motor

  • ✅ Mounting bracket (big deal)

• More complete assembly

• Easier install (less work)

🔧 Item 2

• Comes with:

  • ✅ Motor only

  • ❌ NO bracket

  • ❌ No wiring/hardware

• Buyer must reuse old bracket

🧠 Simple way to understand

• Item 1 = Motor + bracket (complete assembly)

• Item 2 = Motor only (bare part)

💰 eBay selling tip (important for you)

• Your Item 1 is worth more 💵

• Add keywords like:

  • “with bracket”

  • “complete assembly”

• Buyers search for:

  • 84452642 (MOST IMPORTANT SEO 🔥)

✔️ Final answer

• ✔️ Same motor → YES

• ❌ Not identical listing → because Item 1 includes bracket

If you want, I can:

• Make you a perfect 80-character title

• Build a clean fitment + part numbers section

• Help you price it higher than competitors 💰

❌ NO — not exactly the same as your Item 1

🔍 What matches (same core part)

• Same side: Driver / Left

• Same OEM numbers:

  • 84452642 ✅ (main one)

  • 84131859, 23433888, 22935835

• Same vehicles:

  • 2015–2020 Chevrolet Suburban

  • 2015–2020 Cadillac Escalade ESV

  • 2015–2020 GMC Yukon XL

👉 So the motor itself = SAME

⚠️ Main difference (same as Item 2)

🔧 Item 3

• ✅ Motor only

• ❌ No bracket

• ❌ No wiring/hardware

🧩 Your Item 1

• ✅ Motor

• ✅ Mounting bracket (important)

• ✅ More complete unit

🧠 Simple answer

• Item 1 = complete assembly (better 💰)

• Item 3 = bare motor only

💰 eBay tip (this helps you sell faster)

Use this in your title/description:

• “WITH BRACKET (COMPLETE ASSEMBLY)” 🔥

• Add main keyword:

  • 84452642 (MOST SEARCHED)

👉 Buyers often don’t realize the difference — this helps justify higher price

✔️ Final answer

• ✔️ Same motor → YES

• ❌ Same item → NO (missing bracket)

If you want, I can:

• Fix your title to beat competitors

• Show you how much more you can price yours vs motor-only listings 💵

✅ YES — these ARE the same as your Item 1

🔍 What I see from your pictures

• ✅ Both have the mounting bracket

• ✅ Same motor shape + position

• ✅ Same wiring connector

• ✅ Same mounting points

• ✅ Same overall assembly layout

👉 This is NOT a bare motor — this is a complete assembly

🧠 Simple explanation

• Earlier Item 3 description said “motor only” ❌

• But your picture shows:

  • Motor + bracket + wiring = COMPLETE unit

👉 So the listing description is misleading, but the actual part = same as yours

⚠️ Important (for you as seller)

• You and Item 3 are BOTH selling:

  • ✅ Full assembly

  • ❌ Not just motor

💰 eBay advantage tip (VERY IMPORTANT)

Most sellers mess this up. You can win here:

Use keywords like:

• “WITH BRACKET” 🔥

• “COMPLETE ASSEMBLY” 🔥

• 84452642 (MOST SEARCHED)

👉 Buyers often accidentally buy motor-only — your listing will stand out

✔️ Final answer

• ✔️ Same part → YES

• ✔️ Same configuration → YES (both complete assembly)

If you want next:

• I can make you a high-converting 80-char title

• Or show you exact pricing strategy vs motor-only listings 💵