Beautiful vintage My Toy Co. Inc. plush puppy from the late 1950s to early 1960s, preserved in exceptional, near‑mint condition. This piece comes from the early Tots and Teens line and retains its original pre‑ZIP code tag (“New York 10, N.Y.”), confirming production before 1963. Early My Toy plushes are highly collectible, and finding one this clean — with its tag intact — is extremely rare.

This puppy features soft tan and cream plush fur, crisp red felt eye accents, shiny black nose and eyes, and its original pink satin ribbon. The fur is bright and unmatted, the felt is clean, and the tag is fully legible with no fading. Includes the Pennsylvania stuffing compliance seal and original washing instructions. The toy appears unused and displays beautifully.

Features

• Era: 1950s–early 1960s (pre‑ZIP code tag)

• Brand: My Toy Co. Inc., New York

• Line: PLUSH PALS – Tots and Teens

• Material: Soft acrylic plush, felt accents, satin ribbon

• Tag: Original blue hang tag + original fabric care tag

• Condition: Near‑mint vintage condition; fur bright and clean; felt crisp; eyes and nose shiny; ribbon original; seams tight; no matting or yellowing

• Rarity: Early My Toy plushes with intact tags are highly collectible

Early American plush makers like My Toy Co. produced small‑batch toys that rarely survive in clean condition. Pre‑ZIP tags, original ribbons, and intact care labels dramatically increase collector value. This piece is ideal for vintage toy collectors, mid‑century décor lovers, and anyone seeking a pristine example of early plush craftsmanship