The essentials:
These would have gone in the bin if it hadn't been for the nearly new Ridgeway sole. These things are notoriously hard wearing. So if you can get them fixed they'll be good for many miles.

Definitely an ugly duckling. I use a pair of Sharps with a commando sole for my daily dog walk and they are super comfortable and can take on any weather. They look quite delicate in comparison to some country boots you can get (my Loake Wharfdales and Grenson Freds for example) but they're as robust as they come - a bit like that diminutive honey badger scrum half who eats back row forwards for breakfast. 

Anyway. They are what they are. Smoke free home. Shoe trees not included.