They both squeak. Sometime when they open and sometimes when you close them. Both have a discoloration line on the front of pumpkin face. The Fun World Halloween Plastic Pumpkin Pop Up Ghost Cat Squeak Toy is a set of two orange plastic toys designed for Halloween festivities. Made in Hong Kong, these pop-up squeaky toys feature a ghost and cat theme, perfect for adding a fun and festive touch to your Halloween celebrations. The toys are sure to provide entertainment and joy for children and adults alike during the Halloween season.