This 1919-S Buffalo Nickel took the long way through circulation and still showed up with its dignity intact, landing a PCGS VF35 — that sweet spot where it’s basically knocking on XF’s door. San Francisco Buffalos from the teens are notorious for weak strikes and hard circulation, so finding one with bold detail, clean surfaces, and no ugly issues is a win. If you’re building a tough S-mint date run, want a respectable grade without XF premiums, or just like coins with real history and no drama, this one delivers.
1919-S = notoriously tougher than Philly in higher circulated grades
VF35 = premium VF — right before the jump into XF money
Still holds legit horn & braid detail (huge for Buffalos)
Fraser’s design stays artistic even worn
PCGS slab = certified, problem-free, and ready to move
Please review the description and photos carefully before purchasing. Coin grading is subjective; grades and values assigned by third-party grading services (TPGs), as well as references like the Greysheet and Redbook, are provided as a guideline and may not reflect current market values. All photos are taken with an iPhone and a desk lamp on white printing paper—there is no trickery. The coin you see is the coin you will get.
Shipping: Free shipping with tracking on all orders. High-value items may include expedited shipping and/or signature confirmation. Orders ship Monday–Friday after full payment is received.
Returns: 14-day returns accepted unless otherwise noted. Coins must be returned in their original, unopened holders. Gold and silver bullion coins are non-returnable. Any shipping costs covered by the seller will be deducted from the refund.