| 20 | Pete Alonso | |
| 21 | Max Scherzer | |
| 48 | Jacob deGrom | |
| 70 | Darin Ruf | |
| 83 | Tylor Megill | |
| 89 | Brett Baty | Rookie |
| 118 | Eduardo Escobar | |
| 147 | Daniel Vogelbach | |
| 161 | Carlos Carrasco | |
| 171 | Mychal Givens | |
| 187 | Seth Lugo | |
| 190 | Pete Alonso | Combo Cards |
| 199 | Starling Marte | |
| 291 | Team Card | |
| 329 | Mark Canha | |
| 362 | Kodai Senga | Rookie |
| 425 | Justin Verlander | |
| 426 | Jeff McNeil | |
| 450 | Francisco Lindor | |
| 482 | Edwin Díaz | |
| 550 | Mark Vientos | Rookie |
| 612 | Adam Ottavino | |
| 614 | Brandon Nimmo | |
| 615 | Jose Butto | Rookie |
| 644 | Francisco Álvarez | Rookie |
| #US20 Kodai Senga - New York Mets RD |
| #US23 Danny Mendick - New York Mets |
| #US30 Drew Smith - New York Mets |
| #US43 Brooks Raley - New York Mets |
| #US90 Tommy Pham - New York Mets |
| #US105 Tomás Nido - New York Mets |
| #US121 Luis Guillorme - New York Mets |
| #US152 Omar Narváez - New York Mets |
| #US158 Brett Baty - New York Mets RD |
| #US255 Francisco Alvarez - New York Mets RD |
| #US292 Pete Alonso - New York Mets SH |