| Order | Contestant | Song (original artist) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nikko Smith | "Part-Time Lover" (Stevie Wonder) | Safe |
| 2 | Scott Savol | "You Are My Lady" (Freddie Jackson) | Safe |
| 3 | Anthony Fedorov | "Hold on to the Nights" (Richard Marx) | Safe |
| 4 | Bo Bice | "Drift Away" (John Henry Kurtz) | Safe |
| 5 | Travis Tucker | "My Cherie Amour" (Stevie Wonder) | Safe |
| 6 | Constantine Maroulis | "Kiss from a Rose" (Seal) | Safe |
| 7 | David Brown | "Never Can Say Goodbye" (The Jackson 5) | Safe |
| 8 | Jared Yates | "How Could I" (Marc Anthony) | Eliminated |
| 9 | Anwar Robinson | "Moon River" (Andy Williams) | Safe |
| 10 | Judd Harris | "Travelin' Band" (Creedence Clearwater Revival) | Eliminated |
| 11 | Joseph Murena | "How Am I Supposed to Live Without You" (Laura Branigan) | Safe |
| 12 | Mario Vazquez | "Do I Do" (Stevie Wonder) | Safe |
| Order | Contestant | Song (original artist) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Vonzell Solomon | "(Love Is Like a) Heat Wave" (Martha and the Vandellas) | Safe |
| 2 | Amanda Avila | "How Am I Supposed to Live Without You" (Laura Branigan) | Safe |
| 3 | Janay Castine | "I Wanna Love You Forever" (Jessica Simpson) | Safe |
| 4 | Carrie Underwood | "Could've Been" (Tiffany) | Safe |
| 5 | Sarah Mather | "Get Ready" (The Temptations) | Eliminated |
| 6 | Melinda Lira | "The Power of Love" (Jennifer Rush) | Eliminated |
| 7 | Nadia Turner | "The Power of Love" (Ashley Cleveland) | Safe |
| 8 | Celena Rae | "I Will Love Again" (Lara Fabian) | Safe |
| 9 | Mikalah Gordon | "Young Hearts Run Free" (Candi Staton) | Safe |
| 10 | Lindsey Cardinale | "Standing Right Next to Me" (Karla Bonoff) | Safe |
| 11 | Jessica Sierra | "Against All Odds (Take a Look at Me Now)" (Phil Collins) | Safe |
| 12 | Aloha Mischeaux | "Work It Out" (Beyoncé) | Safe |