This is the way our shipping discount works. We take the highest cost shipping item and then add $2.00 shipping for the second item and then only $1.00 shipping for each additional items. An example would be if someone purchased four Starting Lineup items and their highest cost shipping item was $5.99. Their shipping cost would be ($5.99 + $2.00 + $1.00 to $1.00) or $9.99 total shipping for the four items. In order to receive our shipping discount please place your items in your cart and press the request total from seller button. I will then send you an invoice with the discounted shipping cost. You will need to be using a computer. For some reason the request total from seller option is not available on the phone app. Please let me know if you have any questions.