Here are a very nice Automatic Electric telephone number dial cards and Lucite discs exactly like the original.  

There is also North Electric and Kellogg for AE dials.  There are 13 different styles of cards. They are numbered 1 thru 13.

You will get 2 of the same cards and 2 plastic discs for the offered price of $6.89 After your purchase please let us know which number  or numbers you would like.