Both cards included! Both are Authentic. The Caitlin is Graded Mint Condition by PSA Grading Company. The Sophie is Silver Foil Refractor Chase Insert. The Sophie card will come in a brand new thick lucite one touch magnetic closure case. The Caitlin is a Foil Rookie Card. One of her first Rookies pictured in her Fever jersey! We ship FAST, within 24 hours and same day when possible! We ship secure using cardboard boxes with USPS tracking.