This is a really nice black horn button for CJ and FSJ models. The clear plastic lens does have some minor imperfections. Very difficult to photograph due to glare. Sometimes there appears to be a long scratch but it is not. It's simply the glare off the edge of the iPad. All imperfections in the lens are small. There is some spotting that I was unable to polish off. Black vinyl color is still good. Some of the black paint on the outer edge of the lens is starting to wear off and is getting thin. Please examine the pictures closely.