Drawing on two decades of ethnographic research in Sulawesi, Indonesia, Tania Murray Li provides a compelling and detailed account of how capitalist relations have emerged among indigenous highlanders. This transformation centers around their decision to privatize common land in order to cultivate a lucrative crop—cacao. Motivated by hopes of ending poverty and overcoming isolation, some highlanders have prospered, while others have faced the loss of their land and ongoing struggles to support their families.
Li’s richly peopled narrative takes readers deep into the highlanders’ world, exploring the complex dilemmas they encounter as sharp inequalities develop within their communities. Importantly, the book reveals that the winners and losers in this transition are often not strangers but kin and neighbors, highlighting the profound social implications of land privatization and crop commercialization.
The book critically challenges simplistic modernization narratives promoted by development agencies, which often assume that farmers who lose out in the shift to high-value export crops can simply find alternative employment elsewhere. Li emphasizes that decades of uneven and often jobless growth in Indonesia mean that for many newly landless highlanders, the end of their land is truly a dead end, with limited options for economic mobility.
Furthermore, this work has significant implications for social movement activists. It draws attention to instances where enclosure is initiated by farmers themselves, rather than solely being coerced by the state or agribusiness corporations. Li’s focus on the historical, cultural, and ecological dimensions of this conjuncture demonstrates the power and relevance of ethnographic methods in understanding contemporary issues. Her approach underscores the importance of nuanced, context-sensitive analysis for both theory and practice today.