Two symphonies of the Swedish grand-romantic (they don't
come bigger nor bolder than he) Kurt Atterberg (1887-1974) on a 2002
CPO disc. I once heard someone call Atterberg "a John-Williams-wannabe",
which is actually a pretty good bumper-sticker-sized description. Lots
of brass, lots of ornamentation around his melodies, lots to listen to
and keep you happy if you like your heart on your sleeve. Ari Rasilainen
leads the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra in KA's Symphony #2 in F Major (a bit too similar in its finale to the #1, otherwise fine) and Symphony #5 in D minor "Funebre" (talk about "do not go gentle"! This funeral is rarely quieter than a roar).
From the Gramophone review:
Two of the most outwardly Romantic of Atterberg's nine symphonies: the expansive Second and sombre, dramatic Fifth There is a problem with Kurt Atterberg's Second Symphony: not with the music itself, which is richly melodic and gloriously scored, but with the formal design. The central movement, a fusion of adagio and scherzo, culminates in a climax so massive that anything further seems redundant. So the composer thought at its premiere in 1912. The bipartite design was too unconventional for the time and he was prevailed upon to add a finale the following year. If, overall, the right choice, the resulting structure is scarcely traditional. Even Westerberg, in his wonderful account - the first Atterberg recording I ever heard - was not wholly convincing. Rasilainen tackles the problem head-on: adopting slower tempi, the central climax becomes that of just the slow movement rather than a culmination, and to balance this out at the close of the finale he reins in the tempo to produce something equally grandiloquent. Perhaps the close does seem too slow and inflated, but, given the tone of the whole, not out of place. The Fifth (1917-22) also took an unusually long time to complete. When I reviewed Westerberg's rich performance a decade ago, I noted the symphony's 'greater concentration of purpose and more consistent unity of expression than its predecessors'. It remains one of his most successful technically, although overshadowed by Nielsen's exactly contemporaneous Fifth. Both works contained reactions to the horrors of the Great War and while Nielsen's is undeniably the subtler, greater work, Atterberg's is still notable. Rasilainen makes the waltz in the finale really sound like a danse macabre unlike Westerberg but, that aside, there is really nothing between these new rival interpretations. Sound quality has moved on, CPO giving Rasilainen an almost Chandos-like incandescence. Warmly recommended. --Guy Rickards
Disc, booklet, and case are in near-mint condition.
Shipping rates:
US customers: Options are USPS Media Mail at $3.50 for the first CD, $1 for each additional disc paid for at the same time; or USPS Ground Advantage at $4 for the first CD, $1.25 for each additional disc paid for at the same time.
The USPS no longer offers
cheap international shipping of thin envelopes with merchandise, BUT if
you order many discs together the new rate is about the same as it was
before. Therefore...
Canadian customers: Options are Economy shipping, which is First Class but *without* the plastic "jewel" cases, at $15 for ONE TO SEVEN CDs, $24 for EIGHT OR MORE CDs; or First Class *with* the plastic cases included, at $15 for the first CD and $4 for each additional disc.
Customers in other countries: Options are Economy shipping, which is First Class but *without* the plastic
"jewel" cases, at $18 for ONE TO SEVEN CDs, $30 for EIGHT OR MORE CDs; or First Class *with* the plastic cases included, at $18 for the first CD and $6 for each additional disc.
You may wait as long as you wish before paying, to combine auction wins and save on shipping -- especially important for International customers. Please check out my other auctions, here.