These do have some rust from use. Please see photos.

The product is a set of 5 metal jack-o-lantern pumpkin tealight candle holders by HOSLEY USA. They are designed specifically for Halloween, with a copper color and a matte finish. These free-standing candle holders are suitable for tea lights and are made in the United States. The holders are 4 3/4" tall with the handle and 3" wide, making them a stylish and festive addition to your home décor for the holiday season. Easy to clean with a damp cloth, these candle holders are a charming and unique way to celebrate Halloween.