First-Touched TreasuresTM, Virgin ShippingTM
GALACTIC PINSTRIPES.
The AARON JUDGE card from 2023 Topps Cosmic Chrome isn’t subtle — it’s a gravitational pull. Judge in pinstripes, cosmic swirls crashing from edge to edge, and the kind of presence that doesn’t wait for the spotlight.
Low‑population scarcity. GEM MINT sharpness. No compromise.
Cherry Pie Collectibles — where stars don’t align, they swing.
We don’t haggle. We don’t chase. We list. We light cigars. We wait.
Cherry Pie Collectibles isn’t for everyone.
If you clutch pearls, pass us by. If you step correct, welcome.
— Reverend Brick, Chief Pie Filler, Cherry Pie Collectibles, LLC
Pricing Policy:
Firm, Fair, and Final: Our prices reflect the rarity, quality, and value we place on each collectible. We do not negotiate. Each piece is carefully selected, priced, and ready for someone who appreciates its worth. We are not concerned with what it sold for in the past—we set our prices based on what it means to us. If you value it, buy with confidence. If not, move along. Persistent attempts at haggling will earn you a ticket to Blocksville.
Our Promise:
At Cherry Pie Collectibles, we guarantee Virgin ShippingTM. Your item arrives unspoiled and untouched by the grubby hands of amateurs. Honest descriptions, sharp photos, and pristine handling; because we do not mess around.
Photos Do Not Lie:
What you see is what you get. No filters, no tricks. Just an honest representation of what is coming your way.
Graded Items: We handle all graded items with care ensuring they arrive in mint condition. While we make no guarantees about the slab itself (minor scuffs are possible), we disclose any obvious flaws up front.
Raw Cards: May show scratches, edge wear, soft corners, etc. No, we do not provide additional photos—we already provide more than most. No, we will not look at a raw card under a loupe for you. If you need Gem Mint, grab the graded copy. Simple. We follow eBay’s card condition guidelines for raw cards.
Shipping Details:
Prompt and Secure: We pack with care and ship insured ONLY via UPS Ground. WE DO NOT SHIP VIA USPS OR FEDEX. WE DO NOT SHIP TO USPS P.O. BOXES. WE DO NOT OFFER OVERNIGHT, 2-DAY, OR 3-DAY SHIPPING.
Flat Rate: Where a shipping and handling fee applies, you only pay one fee for up to 20 items — as long as you add them all to your cart and check out together. If you place separate orders, you’ll pay shipping each time and receive multiple packages, with no refund for the extra shipping charges. It’s your call.
Virgin ShippingTM: No rough handling, no unseemly fondling—the item stays pristine.
All Sales Final:
No refunds, no returns, no buyer’s remorse. Once it lands in your hands, it’s yours forever—like that tattoo you regret.