TY ORIGINAL Lefty The Donkey Beanie Baby Never taken out it's ORIGINAL PACKAGING Tag Errors 
McDonald's  Retired Ty Beanie Baby Lefty The Donkey  in original package
New in the package. Donkey is unused and undamaged with all tags attached. Some wear on the package from being in storage. Back door is open.

Errors - tush tag says ©1999 TY INC., OAKBROOK, IL. MADE IN CHINA 
package information contradicts: 
Date Introduced: June 15, 1996
Date of Birth: July 4, 1996 
Manufactured for McDonald's Corporation.
©Ty, Inc. Oakbrook, IL U.S.A. 
And the last line of credits 
©2000 McDonald's Corporation, Oak Brook, IL 60523 
There are variations in spelling 
"Oak Brook" vs "Oakbrook" and production dates Lefty the Donkey packaging 
Jetskijohnnys also has Libearty the Bear in store,  2 out of 3 Beanie Babies from American Trio.